My $0.02:
Hunter has appeal because it opens early, closes late, and has a great deal with their CamelCard equivalent - I skied there four times last year for a total of about $35. You MUST get there early, because it's a mob scene later, and I agree with ski999 about it being generally gross. They have challenging back areas, but they are not always open at the times we would go.
Wyndham is supposed to be easier and family oriented, but I've never been there.
Skidude and I had a blast at Greek Peak last year - they allow tree skiing, and had some fun tree runs, which is a nice change from the Pocono areas. We were driving by the area, so I can't comment on the commute.
We went to Belleayre once and had great fun skiing in mashed potatoes at a time when the other areas had closed shop.